5 Comments
User's avatar
Lumpen Space Princeps's avatar

incredible piece

Expand full comment
Arlyn Culwick's avatar

Woah footnote 4! Love it.

Expand full comment
Luis Andrade ⇛ 𝐒𝐩𝐚𝐫𝐡𝐚𝐰𝐤 ℭ ℑ's avatar

I liked this a lot and want to read more. I can't avoid noticing how you managed all that without including sentience in the equations. I mention this because it isn't a given, as in "of course, not all sentient beings are conscious but all conscious beings are sentient" because sentience is what brings qualia to the discourse, specific or inferred, and qualia is what brings color to what otherwise would be a barren, gray-scaled landscape. The graffiti on a Brutalist monument, to apply a visual to it... It is a nuance that, IMHO, perhaps should be explored.

Just paying close attention in my reading and adding some brain droppings, George Carlin would say...

Expand full comment
Mónica Belevan's avatar

A deliberate choice.

Expand full comment
Kaiser Basileus's avatar

Whatever is indistinguishable from consciousness, eg it acts and behaves more or less as we'd expect from creatures we already believe to be conscious, a different that makes no difference, is no difference. That means that ought to be treated as such fit all intents and purposes

However, the type of feedback loop consciousness is, is inseparable and intrinsic to our biological embodiment. The kind of feedback loop that develops in an AI will be inherently different. And it will need a different name.

Expand full comment